For sale

I don't have enough recent comparable sales to call this one's price, but new this week. Here's everything I've got on it — ask me anything.

St. Catharines · Niagara Region · Downtown

58 Ontario Street

Triplex

MLS® #X13809304

Listed for$998,5002 days on market

5 bed 4 bath 5 parking 3500-5000 sq ft~$235/sq ft

New this week
5 schools within 1 km
Transit stop ~270 m

Free · about 10 seconds

Is $998,500 a fair price?

See AskEmma’s read of this asking price against recent comparable sales — how far above or below, and the range they sold in.

No obligation · unsubscribe anytime

Est. all-in monthly~$5,309/momortgage + property tax + maintenance · 20% down · example rate (compounded semi-annually) — the math on the list price, not a quote or what you can afford. For real rates, Alex can connect you with a mortgage pro.

On the map

Loading map…

This home below comps above in lineOpen full map →

5 schools within ~1 km · nearest transit stop ~0.27 km

Property information

What house buyers ask first

Lot size: 50 × 99 ft
Square footage: 3500-5000 sq ft
Property tax: $7,956 / yr
Parking: 5 spaces · None
Basement: Full

Property summary

Property type: Triplex
Style: 3-Storey
Lot size: 50 × 99 ft
Parking: 5 spaces · None
Heating: Heat Pump
Air conditioning: Wall Unit(s)
Basement: Full
Kitchens: 3
Exterior: Brick
Property tax: $7,956 / yr
MLS®: X13809304

As stated by the MLS®, nothing inferred.

Nearby homes for sale

Below-comps first · all nearby homes shown, not just the good-value ones.

Detached

$459,000

Below recent sales

192A ONTARIO Street

3+1 bed · 2 bath·700-1100 sq ft·4 parking

St. Catharines · Niagara Region

Listed 12 days ago · RE/MAX Garden City Realty Inc, Brokerage

Detached

$319,900

Below recent sales

177 James Street

2 bed · 1 bath·1100-1500 sq ft·3 parking

St. Catharines · Niagara Region

Listed 13 days ago · Royal LePage Nrc Realty

Detached

$549,900

Below recent sales

17 Gerrard Street

2 bed · 2 bath·1100-1500 sq ft·3 parking

St. Catharines · Niagara Region

Listed 1 day ago · Realty Network

Detached

$759,000

Below recent sales

8 Trafalgar Street

3 bed · 3 bath·1500-2000 sq ft·8 parking

St. Catharines · Niagara Region

Listed 9 days ago · RE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd, Brokerage

Detached

$429,000

Below recent sales

9 Woodland Avenue

3 bed · 2 bath·700-1100 sq ft·3 parking

St. Catharines · Niagara Region

Listed 12 days ago · Realty Network

Condo Apartment

$289,900

Below recent sales

7 Gale Crescent, Unit 302

2 bed · 2 bath·1000-1199 sq ft·1 parking·$1,105/mo fee

St. Catharines · Niagara Region

Listed 8 days ago · Royal LePage Nrc Realty

The numbers that matter

Property tax: $7,956/yr
Est. all-in: ~$5,309/mo

Nearby rental listings are facts. Whether it works as a rental is a chat with Alex — not a number I’ll put on it.

Schools

Schools near this home, closest first by straight-line distance. These are factual locations — AskEmma doesn’t rate or rank schools.

St Nicholas Catholic Elementary SchoolCatholic · Elementary & Secondary · Niagara CDSB0.6 km
ÉÉC Immaculée-ConceptionCatholic · Elementary & Secondary · French · CS catholique MonAvenir0.7 km
St Catharines Collegiate Institute and Vocational SchoolPublic · Secondary · DSB Niagara0.8 km
Agate Private SchoolPrivate · Elementary & Secondary · ..0.8 km
Harriet Tubman Public SchoolPublic · Elementary & Secondary · DSB Niagara1.0 km
Ridley CollegePrivate · Elementary & Secondary · ..1.1 km

Locations: Open Database of Educational Facilities (ODEF), Statistics Canada v2.1 (2022) · Open Government Licence – Canada. School locations as of 2022 — confirm current catchment and enrolment with the school board. For official provincial results, check EQAO.

Getting around

Public transit near this home, by straight-line distance. Factual locations from OpenStreetMap — not walking time, and not a rating.

St. Catharines Downtown TerminalNearest transit · Bus stop~270 m
St. CatharinesNearest GO / rail · GO / regional rail~1.5 km

Locations: OpenStreetMap public-transit stops, © OpenStreetMap contributors · Open Database Licence (ODbL). Stop locations from OpenStreetMap — confirm current routes and service with the transit agency.

Community — St. Catharines

$543KMedian sold

39Median days on market

96.7%Sale-to-list

Median sold price · St. Catharines1-yr -3% · 3-yr -12%

Source: TRREB sold data via Repliers · all property types

Neighbourhood demographics — St. Catharines

136,803Population (2021)

44.8Median age

$72,000Median household income

64.4%Home owners

35.6%Renters

2.3Avg household size

Source: Statistics Canada, 2021 Census

Description & details

Positioned on a prominent downtown corner, 58 Ontario Street presents a rare opportunity for owner-occupiers, investors, or live-work users to acquire a fully vacant 3,528 sq. ft. architecturally distinctive landmark building with exceptional zoning flexibility (C5-92) in the downtown core. Zoning permits a broad range of residential and commercial uses, allowing the property to function as entirely commercial, entirely residential, or mixed-use, while benefiting from the sought-after downtown parking exemption. Currently configured with a beautifully appointed 1,450 sq. ft. commercial main floor and two self-contained residential apartments above, the property offers three income streams with potential gross annual income of approximately $75,000 based on projected market rents, with additional upside through commercial leasing or owner occupancy. Showcasing original millwork, pocket doors, stained and leaded glass, refinished hardwood flooring, and other period details rarely found in commercial properties today, the building seamlessly combines historic character with modern functionality. Additional features include updated washrooms and kitchens, five ductless splits, full basement storage, separate hydro meters, five on-site parking spaces (2 tandem). Located in the heart of Downtown St. Catharines' heritage district, steps from the Performing Arts Centre, Meridian Centre, Brock University's Marilyn I. Walker School, restaurants and cafés, the area continues to benefit from ongoing residential intensification and commercial reinvestment, supporting long-term demand for both residential and commercial space.

The data only goes so far — condition, light and layout are worth seeing in person, with a home inspection, before you commit.

Listed by ROYAL LEPAGE NRC REALTY. Showings via AskEmma by Alex Goodman, Sales Representative, RE/MAX Your Community Realty, Brokerage.